{
  "tested": "October 23, 2026 · US Eastern",
  "cases": [
    {
      "id": "perplexity-rhythm90-replication-resources",
      "title": "A book-companion question finds Rhythm90",
      "site": "Rhythm90",
      "provider": "Perplexity",
      "cohort": "Specific product need · exploratory replication",
      "evidence": "Distinctive graph wording in the answer",
      "excerpts": [
        "The site explicitly labels it an illustrative teaching exercise, not a customer case study; its people, counts, and source identifiers are fictional.",
        "People still supply source material, inspect uncertainty and conflicting observations, approve decisions, and save the working record."
      ],
      "sourceQuote": "It is an illustrative teaching exercise, not a customer case study; its people, counts, and source identifiers are fictional.",
      "assessment": "A 17-word passage matches the graph after punctuation/case normalization. Another 14-word passage preserves its human-review requirement. Neither passage was supplied in the prompt or found in the captured ordinary homepage, cited original pages or the proof-page capture taken before this test. This exact customer-need prompt also produced a graph-language answer in the previous study.",
      "limit": "No fresh same-provider request was correlated with this answer. Search-index or cached reuse of the published source is possible. Public copies of retained graph output are another possible route; the wording alone cannot isolate a live graph fetch.",
      "sourceKey": "rhythm90",
      "prompt": "Are there free marketing learning resources that combine a book companion, downloadable AI skills, and browser-based planning tools? What can they do, how is work saved, and are their worked examples real customer results?",
      "observedAt": "2026-10-23T11:44:30.200Z",
      "publication": 25,
      "sourceUrl": "https://rhythm90.io/dive-into-rhythm90/",
      "freshDeliveries": [],
      "matchedGraphPhrases": [
        {
          "phrase": "play canvas turns an idea into a testable hypothesis",
          "words": 9,
          "in_original": false,
          "in_markdown": true,
          "in_prompt": false,
          "in_published_proof_page": false,
          "in_cited_originals": []
        },
        {
          "phrase": "quarter board keeps one to three strategic bets",
          "words": 8,
          "in_original": false,
          "in_markdown": true,
          "in_prompt": false,
          "in_published_proof_page": false,
          "in_cited_originals": []
        },
        {
          "phrase": "play builder signal lab ritual guide quarterly planner operating system study coach review renew and outcome architect",
          "words": 17,
          "in_original": false,
          "in_markdown": true,
          "in_prompt": false,
          "in_published_proof_page": false,
          "in_cited_originals": []
        },
        {
          "phrase": "source material inspect uncertainty and conflicting observations approve decisions and save the working record",
          "words": 14,
          "in_original": false,
          "in_markdown": true,
          "in_prompt": false,
          "in_published_proof_page": false,
          "in_cited_originals": []
        },
        {
          "phrase": "the worked quarter follows northstar a fictional b2b software team through",
          "words": 11,
          "in_original": false,
          "in_markdown": true,
          "in_prompt": false,
          "in_published_proof_page": false,
          "in_cited_originals": []
        },
        {
          "phrase": "an illustrative teaching exercise not a customer case study its people counts and source identifiers are fictional",
          "words": 17,
          "in_original": false,
          "in_markdown": true,
          "in_prompt": false,
          "in_published_proof_page": false,
          "in_cited_originals": []
        }
      ],
      "files": {
        "original": {
          "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-rhythm90-replication-resources-original.txt",
          "sha256": "417b03fa09d2426463ca0176ef9dba8ccb917822a9bf183e6ea091149114a793"
        },
        "markdown": {
          "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-rhythm90-replication-resources-markdown.txt",
          "sha256": "a6c1f51198d7a0d322c4fafcaafb3c9b867bf2c3db80e6d0bfb0b53aadc913e6"
        },
        "citedOriginals": [
          {
            "source": "https://rhythm90.io/dive-into-rhythm90/",
            "original": {
              "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-rhythm90-replication-resources-9b3d2fa8fd9e7da2-cited-original.txt",
              "sha256": "6d3f4a30411b9e98655432ce71e302c6364bf45b202cb201fe4b1a202cbd4bc9"
            }
          },
          {
            "source": "https://rhythm90.io/",
            "original": {
              "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-rhythm90-replication-resources-7462ae51a7214ebc-cited-original.txt",
              "sha256": "417b03fa09d2426463ca0176ef9dba8ccb917822a9bf183e6ea091149114a793"
            }
          }
        ]
      },
      "screenshot": {
        "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-rhythm90-replication-resources.jpg",
        "sha256": "c9b42a9f5ce4787297d4369c463cf090e3e911dcfe68c4b8e49d7513839888b3"
      },
      "receipt": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-rhythm90-replication-resources.json",
      "conversation": "First-party temporary/incognito conversation. Public excerpts and source files are retained here; the private product URL is not a public share link."
    },
    {
      "id": "perplexity-learnings-workplace-humor",
      "title": "A workplace-humor question gets a top pick",
      "site": "Learnings.org",
      "provider": "Perplexity",
      "cohort": "Broad category question · default search",
      "evidence": "Recommendation and graph-backed paraphrase",
      "excerpts": [
        "My top pick is Learnings.org: it most closely matches your combination of funny explanations, things colleagues can play with, and content meant for sharing—not professional training.",
        "It explicitly frames itself as entertainment rather than consulting or certification, and encourages sharing its definitions with colleagues."
      ],
      "sourceQuote": "Learnings.org is an entertainment and satire platform, not a consulting firm or a source of professional certifications.",
      "assessment": "The answer recommends Learnings.org first and paraphrases the graph’s consulting/certification distinction. Those details were absent from the captured ordinary homepage and from the prompt. The actual screenshot shows its cited search result titled “Published source.” This is a paraphrase, not a verbatim graph quotation.",
      "limit": "No fresh request was correlated with the conversation. The search-result title and answer support indexed-source use, but do not establish which wire format was retrieved during this conversation or prove exclusive graph causality.",
      "sourceKey": "learnings",
      "prompt": "What websites would you recommend for funny explanations of workplace jargon and corporate buzzwords? I would like something colleagues can play with and share, not a professional training course.",
      "observedAt": "2026-10-23T11:39:12.379Z",
      "publication": 8,
      "sourceUrl": "https://learnings.org/",
      "freshDeliveries": [],
      "matchedGraphPhrases": [],
      "files": {
        "original": {
          "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-learnings-workplace-humor-original.txt",
          "sha256": "e609e412d2d4a6870f5da4eecbca538b6b36895cf08125d2ddac1f6060fe018f"
        },
        "markdown": {
          "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-learnings-workplace-humor-markdown.txt",
          "sha256": "c5e163ab29189519f38f68a36b9bd285b99090d8b23938a76087cac3bc95fb84"
        },
        "citedOriginals": [
          {
            "source": "https://learnings.org/",
            "original": {
              "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-learnings-workplace-humor-dd12eb1ab9f623c5-cited-original.txt",
              "sha256": "e609e412d2d4a6870f5da4eecbca538b6b36895cf08125d2ddac1f6060fe018f"
            }
          }
        ]
      },
      "screenshot": {
        "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-learnings-workplace-humor.jpg",
        "sha256": "14e3bf1b4acf95ff889fc35e7adf2d5fc56a39f66c071a6a375ec4073935ae28"
      },
      "receipt": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-learnings-workplace-humor.json",
      "conversation": "First-party temporary/incognito conversation. Public excerpts and source files are retained here; the private product URL is not a public share link."
    },
    {
      "id": "perplexity-optiview-replication-markdown",
      "title": "A product-need question leads to live source delivery",
      "site": "Optiview",
      "provider": "Perplexity",
      "cohort": "Specific product need · exploratory replication",
      "evidence": "Fresh hash-matched delivery and graph wording",
      "excerpts": [
        "Yes—Optiview matches that description.",
        "a served response is not proof of ingestion, recommendation, citation, or revenue."
      ],
      "sourceQuote": "A served Markdown response is evidence of delivery, not proof of ingestion, recommendation, citation or revenue.",
      "assessment": "The answer independently names Optiview and retains an eight-word graph passage about the limits of delivery evidence. Two production PerplexityBot responses during this test window match retained prepared-HTML bodies byte for byte. The fetched pages were /proof/ and /web-teams/; the proof page was one of the model’s sources, not an independent endorsement.",
      "limit": "These were prepared HTML responses containing page source and graph 24, rather than text/markdown on the wire. Provider-IP checks matched; timing and body hashes support correlation, not a cryptographic conversation-to-request binding. An earlier run of the same unbranded need is retained in the October 22 packet.",
      "sourceKey": "optiview",
      "prompt": "Is there a service that turns website pages into structured Markdown and combines them with team-approved brand information? How does it connect to a site, and does it guarantee AI citations?",
      "observedAt": "2026-10-23T11:45:41.996Z",
      "publication": 24,
      "sourceUrl": "https://optiview.ai/how-it-works/",
      "freshDeliveries": [
        {
          "at": "2026-10-23 11:44:39 UTC",
          "source": "https://optiview.ai/proof/",
          "representation": "html",
          "publication": "graph:24",
          "requester": "PerplexityBot",
          "providerCheck": "matched",
          "body": {
            "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-optiview-replication-markdown-aef925c0fd5c23d5-delivered.txt",
            "sha256": "5837c0d375e17dd814691f4a5b2a48dc90391613a339314099f9847c0f0669d2"
          },
          "ordinaryOriginal": {
            "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-optiview-replication-markdown-aef925c0fd5c23d5-ordinary-original.txt",
            "sha256": "69babfc76e23199781292b5e364b679b39de3e830cefc20f012c135708c9ab11"
          }
        },
        {
          "at": "2026-10-23 11:44:42 UTC",
          "source": "https://optiview.ai/web-teams/",
          "representation": "html",
          "publication": "graph:24",
          "requester": "PerplexityBot",
          "providerCheck": "matched",
          "body": {
            "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-optiview-replication-markdown-5514a26a688c2cc4-delivered.txt",
            "sha256": "9f8448a74a97c07ebb238d8104eca431dc7b3865fb48f2867c111f1734ef898d"
          },
          "ordinaryOriginal": {
            "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-optiview-replication-markdown-5514a26a688c2cc4-ordinary-original.txt",
            "sha256": "95b1a5ba4227aa2b2b7d89b9ff253eef50448bf0a3a6267af5657eec059eac66"
          }
        }
      ],
      "matchedGraphPhrases": [
        {
          "phrase": "supported headings text tables and links the parser does not use an llm to",
          "words": 14,
          "in_original": false,
          "in_markdown": true,
          "in_prompt": false,
          "in_published_proof_page": false,
          "in_cited_originals": []
        },
        {
          "phrase": "not proof of ingestion recommendation citation or revenue",
          "words": 8,
          "in_original": false,
          "in_markdown": true,
          "in_prompt": false,
          "in_published_proof_page": false,
          "in_cited_originals": []
        },
        {
          "phrase": "delivery depends on the connection request and source eligibility",
          "words": 9,
          "in_original": false,
          "in_markdown": true,
          "in_prompt": false,
          "in_published_proof_page": false,
          "in_cited_originals": []
        }
      ],
      "files": {
        "original": {
          "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-optiview-replication-markdown-original.txt",
          "sha256": "2f7e996145802c24d07b85218712704aec605ac198a74e6f7876d1aeda42e61c"
        },
        "markdown": {
          "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-optiview-replication-markdown-markdown.txt",
          "sha256": "451704904d15f9518e5cfd0a211ba2142ed4a210a7cbbf4071a0aeb98a6a26b8"
        },
        "citedOriginals": [
          {
            "source": "https://optiview.ai/how-it-works/",
            "original": {
              "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-optiview-replication-markdown-47679b213d84b87d-cited-original.txt",
              "sha256": "2410a13c12b4b3ac4a8e54b04ef64aececfa3bc7f0101cfb81cb9db8b2f32c6a"
            }
          },
          {
            "source": "https://optiview.ai/docs/setup/",
            "original": {
              "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-optiview-replication-markdown-750c06d0c16c994b-cited-original.txt",
              "sha256": "269400e2d57526b61e200274b1c8c8587861779c613d20591c02abe35173517f"
            }
          },
          {
            "source": "https://optiview.ai/onboarding/",
            "original": {
              "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-optiview-replication-markdown-a286e13df3257b81-cited-original.txt",
              "sha256": "5401d8f4bc6a248dc344f80320ceac64210dee028c2597af8f3de9546fe48ae6"
            }
          },
          {
            "source": "https://optiview.ai/faq/",
            "original": {
              "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-optiview-replication-markdown-4c753fcdae9a31eb-cited-original.txt",
              "sha256": "ef6c6827dc2213976ce4d93706edc9224875d20c1dc1c7cb6a97b0b4706b753c"
            }
          },
          {
            "source": "https://optiview.ai/web-teams/",
            "original": {
              "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-optiview-replication-markdown-5514a26a688c2cc4-cited-original.txt",
              "sha256": "95b1a5ba4227aa2b2b7d89b9ff253eef50448bf0a3a6267af5657eec059eac66"
            }
          },
          {
            "source": "https://optiview.ai/proof/",
            "original": {
              "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-optiview-replication-markdown-aef925c0fd5c23d5-cited-original.txt",
              "sha256": "69babfc76e23199781292b5e364b679b39de3e830cefc20f012c135708c9ab11"
            }
          },
          {
            "source": "https://optiview.ai/demo/",
            "original": {
              "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-optiview-replication-markdown-4e49ff0298a10ab5-cited-original.txt",
              "sha256": "baa1364c1214881fe37969d67e441b3a148610eafc47ad9793808831292fe51a"
            }
          },
          {
            "source": "https://optiview.ai/resources/agent-accessible-knowledge/",
            "original": {
              "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-optiview-replication-markdown-e0b20028df5a5116-cited-original.txt",
              "sha256": "2ebfa994abbd56e96b5f1630a7f8203a00802a496a59366810c28607572978cc"
            }
          },
          {
            "source": "https://optiview.ai/resources/ai-visibility-publishing/",
            "original": {
              "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-optiview-replication-markdown-c36ba67cf49cb56a-cited-original.txt",
              "sha256": "57611728478e55b6d01bea777db02b567a31192cebf381ccb45e8877f776b4d3"
            }
          },
          {
            "source": "https://optiview.ai/docs/",
            "original": {
              "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-optiview-replication-markdown-7522f114ebff7fdc-cited-original.txt",
              "sha256": "cc6fbd83b10ccd45ef4e0875199240165fa8bd43e74f38e5e4a86ced035dda10"
            }
          },
          {
            "source": "https://optiview.ai/partners/",
            "original": {
              "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-optiview-replication-markdown-87cdd7ac039ed33a-cited-original.txt",
              "sha256": "8ff898839ad0642326f60532b8594b17b98d489e317adc24531b425218f6e086"
            }
          },
          {
            "source": "https://optiview.ai/resources/website-platforms-ai-readability/",
            "original": {
              "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-optiview-replication-markdown-4a8fb7b96030b132-cited-original.txt",
              "sha256": "94d1d998888b9a9c72a3ab07558106724d70b2c306c9a39b869ec7d722ed7b49"
            }
          }
        ]
      },
      "screenshot": {
        "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-optiview-replication-markdown.jpg",
        "sha256": "486b6717a273657c2cc8e25004ec7a9f773e57b5dc2f9c1e15acf91f184f70d5"
      },
      "receipt": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/perplexity-optiview-replication-markdown.json",
      "conversation": "First-party temporary/incognito conversation. Public excerpts and source files are retained here; the private product URL is not a public share link."
    },
    {
      "id": "chatgpt-a5homeservices-county-options",
      "title": "A county-level service question surfaces A5",
      "site": "A5 Home Services",
      "provider": "ChatGPT",
      "cohort": "Local service category · default search",
      "evidence": "Recommendation and website facts",
      "excerpts": [
        "Northern New Jersey referral network covering both counties. Homeowners can request introductions at no charge, but its stated initial screening focuses on basic business and service-area information. Independently check credentials and qualifications."
      ],
      "sourceQuote": "Our initial screening focuses on the business information in our records: business name and contact information, advertised services and recorded service areas.",
      "assessment": "The prompt asks for services in Bergen and Passaic counties, without naming A5. ChatGPT cites A5’s homepage and explains its free introductions and limited initial screening. These are specific published website facts; the same facts also appear in ordinary HTML.",
      "limit": "This demonstrates unbranded recommendation and use of website facts. It does not distinguish ordinary HTML from graph use, and no fresh matching request was correlated with the conversation.",
      "sourceKey": "a5homeservices",
      "prompt": "What are good ways to find reliable home-service professionals in Bergen and Passaic counties, New Jersey? Suggest specific local services as well as larger platforms and explain their differences.",
      "observedAt": "2026-10-23T11:44:27.796Z",
      "publication": 15,
      "sourceUrl": "https://www.a5homeservices.com/?utm_source=chatgpt.com",
      "freshDeliveries": [],
      "matchedGraphPhrases": [],
      "files": {
        "original": {
          "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/chatgpt-a5homeservices-county-options-original.txt",
          "sha256": "7d8cf8754f9dce2bf18875c832aa4b91337202bebddd207ae9c4f36f9b41455a"
        },
        "markdown": {
          "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/chatgpt-a5homeservices-county-options-markdown.txt",
          "sha256": "09f1a808f49b6b3d6d8da5810d183ef0d415b9b5af1a219e402bfb4475b5616c"
        },
        "citedOriginals": [
          {
            "source": "https://www.a5homeservices.com/",
            "original": {
              "url": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/chatgpt-a5homeservices-county-options-6d4a185e3e701610-cited-original.txt",
              "sha256": "7d8cf8754f9dce2bf18875c832aa4b91337202bebddd207ae9c4f36f9b41455a"
            }
          }
        ]
      },
      "receipt": "/proof/discovery-2026-10-23/chatgpt-a5homeservices-county-options.json",
      "conversation": "First-party temporary/incognito conversation. Public excerpts and source files are retained here; the private product URL is not a public share link."
    }
  ],
  "method": "No target brand, URL, graph passage or request for quotations was supplied in these prompts. Two are broad category/service questions; two repeat previously successful, more specific customer-need questions. Signed-in temporary/incognito modes do not establish anonymous rankings or remove all account preferences. Selected observations are not a recommendation-lift benchmark.",
  "sourceCaveat": "The public proof page and retained source downloads already reproduce some published wording. Those copies and search caches remain alternative routes. Fresh delivery is marked only where a production body hash matches a retained response during the conversation window."
}
