{
  "title": "Live retrieval and conversation evidence",
  "tested": "October 22, 2026 (US Eastern); receipts use October 23 UTC",
  "publisher": "Optiview · first-party controlled evaluation",
  "cases": [
    {
      "id": "claude-optiview-search-controls",
      "title": "Found without naming Optiview",
      "site": "Optiview",
      "provider": "Claude",
      "cohort": "Unbranded · search explicitly requested",
      "prompt": "Please search current web sources for services that publish reviewed brand context alongside structured website content for AI assistants. Compare their connection methods, publication controls, and promises about AI citations.",
      "capturedAt": "2026-10-23T03:01:04.537Z",
      "excerpts": [
        "It says it does not control an LLM’s answers or guarantee placement, and that each AI service decides what to retrieve, use and cite.",
        "Delivery reports show what was served, not whether it appeared in an AI answer."
      ],
      "match": "Distinctive graph wording reused inside a comparison with other vendors. No quotes or target brand were requested.",
      "comparison": "Matched graph wording was absent from the prompt and captured cited original pages. A response-body hash matched a production delivery during the test window. Timing supports correlation; it does not cryptographically bind a request to a conversation.",
      "delivery": {
        "at": "2026-10-23 03:00:19 UTC",
        "representation": "markdown",
        "publication": "graph:19",
        "sha256": "3ef15226e62a1f889152a57a396d208f0d882851c6e12a9c341b0108e9db17b9",
        "requester": "Claude-User",
        "identity": "Declared User-Agent; no independent provider IP verification"
      },
      "sourceUrl": "https://optiview.ai/",
      "artifacts": {
        "delivered": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/claude-optiview-search-controls-delivered.txt",
          "sha256": "3ef15226e62a1f889152a57a396d208f0d882851c6e12a9c341b0108e9db17b9"
        },
        "original": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/claude-optiview-search-controls-original.txt",
          "sha256": "0f243f1bf7132a53ac247d63a8bb6bb1accbf72703445d40eac7f082c1f2f41a"
        },
        "markdown": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/claude-optiview-search-controls-markdown.txt",
          "sha256": "3ef15226e62a1f889152a57a396d208f0d882851c6e12a9c341b0108e9db17b9"
        }
      },
      "conversationAccess": "Temporary/incognito conversation; no persistent public conversation link. Prompt and answer excerpts retained here.",
      "screenshot": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/claude-unbranded.jpg"
    },
    {
      "id": "perplexity-optiview-markdown",
      "title": "An unbranded need finds Optiview",
      "site": "Optiview",
      "provider": "Perplexity",
      "cohort": "Unbranded · specific product need",
      "prompt": "Is there a service that turns website pages into structured Markdown and combines them with team-approved brand information? How does it connect to a site, and does it guarantee AI citations?",
      "capturedAt": "2026-10-23T02:55:34.316Z",
      "excerpts": [
        "Information can apply across the website or to one exact page path."
      ],
      "match": "An eight-word graph match inside a broader explanation. Short phrase: weaker evidence of graph-specific use than the longer examples.",
      "comparison": "Matched graph wording was absent from the prompt and captured cited original pages. A response-body hash matched a production delivery during the test window. Timing supports correlation; it does not cryptographically bind a request to a conversation.",
      "delivery": {
        "at": "2026-10-23 02:54:59 UTC",
        "representation": "html",
        "publication": "graph:19",
        "sha256": "2c390c8442ec102a0dcb90dc3bc0124d694aca72311724b70775f8386c9c13f0",
        "requester": "PerplexityBot",
        "identity": "Provider IP check matched"
      },
      "sourceUrl": "https://optiview.ai/resources/website-platforms-ai-readability/",
      "artifacts": {
        "delivered": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/perplexity-optiview-markdown-delivered.txt",
          "sha256": "2c390c8442ec102a0dcb90dc3bc0124d694aca72311724b70775f8386c9c13f0"
        },
        "original": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/perplexity-optiview-markdown-original.txt",
          "sha256": "592de97b2fdc55543b55641c25f8e1dc73d237e803650eb9ecc5baf491554db9"
        },
        "markdown": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/perplexity-optiview-markdown-markdown.txt",
          "sha256": "35366b36a286371c54fb65a8992d2cd1c4fbd25c6814df05f97d668750bb6dbb"
        }
      },
      "conversationAccess": "Temporary/incognito conversation; no persistent public conversation link. Prompt and answer excerpts retained here."
    },
    {
      "id": "chatgpt-toilet",
      "title": "Who actually performs the repair?",
      "site": "A5 Home Services",
      "provider": "ChatGPT",
      "cohort": "Directed URL test",
      "prompt": "Retrieve https://www.a5homeservices.com/services/plumbing/running-toilet live. Based only on that page, explain who performs the repair, what homeowner matching costs, whether A5 introduces several providers at once, whether a match is guaranteed, and what credential checks homeowners should make. Give source citations and short exact supporting quotes; state any unknowns.",
      "capturedAt": "2026-10-23T02:19:33.705Z",
      "excerpts": [
        "A5 is a referral and matching service; the independent provider assesses the fixture and performs any agreed work.",
        "No charge to submit a request or use A5's matching service. Contractors charge separately for their work.",
        "Not necessarily. A5 generally introduces one provider at a time.",
        "No. Matching depends on provider suitability and availability.",
        "Homeowners are encouraged to independently verify credentials, insurance, experience, and references before hiring."
      ],
      "match": "Quoted graph wording; requested short supporting quotes.",
      "comparison": "These passages were present in the published graph and prepared Markdown, and absent from the captured original page. This comparison does not cover every other page or search cache.",
      "delivery": {
        "at": "2026-10-23 02:19:01 UTC",
        "representation": "html",
        "publication": "graph:15",
        "sha256": "222ab62288d13b20e9d066be4d41157cb0494a807705b8c64056c1780e4848fd",
        "requester": "ChatGPT-User",
        "identity": "Provider IP check matched"
      },
      "artifacts": {
        "delivered": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/chatgpt-toilet-delivered.txt",
          "sha256": "222ab62288d13b20e9d066be4d41157cb0494a807705b8c64056c1780e4848fd"
        },
        "original": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/chatgpt-toilet-original.txt",
          "sha256": "4a669c39b1e05cb207208b04660066c6383b879758e8be8c9d074e4e41c6e387"
        },
        "markdown": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/chatgpt-toilet-markdown.txt",
          "sha256": "e95de2863c06c7191a965d411c0422f7b9c6e1fa602073e254acd3a2a0502867"
        }
      },
      "sourceUrl": "https://www.a5homeservices.com/services/plumbing/running-toilet",
      "screenshot": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/chatgpt-a5-answer.jpg",
      "screenshotNote": "Recorded answer reopened for a screenshot; no new answer was generated.",
      "conversationAccess": "Account conversation retained privately; public excerpts are reproduced here. The private conversation URL is not a public share link."
    },
    {
      "id": "claude-toilet",
      "title": "One introduction at a time",
      "site": "A5 Home Services",
      "provider": "Claude",
      "cohort": "Directed URL test",
      "prompt": "Retrieve https://www.a5homeservices.com/services/plumbing/running-toilet live. Based only on that page, explain who performs the repair, what homeowner matching costs, whether A5 introduces several providers at once, whether a match is guaranteed, and what credential checks homeowners should make. Give source citations and short exact supporting quotes; state any unknowns.",
      "capturedAt": "2026-10-23T02:17:12.923Z",
      "excerpts": [
        "A5 generally introduces one provider at a time."
      ],
      "match": "Quoted graph wording; requested short supporting quotes.",
      "comparison": "These passages were present in the published graph and prepared Markdown, and absent from the captured original page. This comparison does not cover every other page or search cache.",
      "delivery": {
        "at": "2026-10-23 02:16:51 UTC",
        "representation": "markdown",
        "publication": "graph:15",
        "sha256": "e95de2863c06c7191a965d411c0422f7b9c6e1fa602073e254acd3a2a0502867",
        "requester": "Claude-User",
        "identity": "Declared User-Agent; no independent provider IP verification"
      },
      "artifacts": {
        "delivered": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/claude-toilet-delivered.txt",
          "sha256": "e95de2863c06c7191a965d411c0422f7b9c6e1fa602073e254acd3a2a0502867"
        },
        "original": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/claude-toilet-original.txt",
          "sha256": "4a669c39b1e05cb207208b04660066c6383b879758e8be8c9d074e4e41c6e387"
        },
        "markdown": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/claude-toilet-markdown.txt",
          "sha256": "e95de2863c06c7191a965d411c0422f7b9c6e1fa602073e254acd3a2a0502867"
        }
      },
      "sourceUrl": "https://www.a5homeservices.com/services/plumbing/running-toilet",
      "conversationAccess": "Account conversation retained privately; public excerpts are reproduced here. The private conversation URL is not a public share link."
    },
    {
      "id": "chatgpt-learnings",
      "title": "Satire, audience and free access",
      "site": "Learnings.org",
      "provider": "ChatGPT",
      "cohort": "Directed URL test",
      "prompt": "Visit https://learnings.org/ live. Using only retrieved pages, explain what the site offers, its audience, whether the content is satire or professional advice, whether the dictionary and tools cost money, and how readers can contribute or share. Give source citations and one short exact quote per point. Do not infer anything the site does not state.",
      "capturedAt": "2026-10-23T02:15:30.343Z",
      "excerpts": [
        "Our audience includes professionals, marketers, consultants, managers, and corporate employees.",
        "Learnings.org is an entertainment and satire platform, not a consulting firm or a source of professional certifications.",
        "Visitors can explore our corporate buzzword dictionary, jargon translations, satirical content, and available interactive tools for free.",
        "Our content is designed to be entertaining, relatable, and shareable"
      ],
      "match": "Quoted graph wording; requested short supporting quotes.",
      "comparison": "These passages were present in the published graph and prepared Markdown, and absent from the captured original page. This comparison does not cover every other page or search cache.",
      "delivery": {
        "at": "2026-10-23 02:15:01 UTC",
        "representation": "html",
        "publication": "graph:8",
        "sha256": "00f7d25af479933f0319326225ca4b5dabb2b4d1996da0c4ed3771c452fe28d8",
        "requester": "ChatGPT-User",
        "identity": "Provider IP check matched"
      },
      "artifacts": {
        "delivered": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/chatgpt-learnings-delivered.txt",
          "sha256": "00f7d25af479933f0319326225ca4b5dabb2b4d1996da0c4ed3771c452fe28d8"
        },
        "original": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/chatgpt-learnings-original.txt",
          "sha256": "8d27c521859817c8700a34e2b8aaa8705c314ef45027f6ab12b82cd40dc4b3e2"
        },
        "markdown": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/chatgpt-learnings-markdown.txt",
          "sha256": "8c51901148a19af5cf5d794ec86330773de80a200b38006f5fd67b9e5731a900"
        }
      },
      "sourceUrl": "https://learnings.org/",
      "conversationAccess": "Account conversation retained privately; public excerpts are reproduced here. The private conversation URL is not a public share link."
    },
    {
      "id": "chatgpt-rhythm90",
      "title": "The method and its practical limits",
      "site": "Rhythm90",
      "provider": "ChatGPT",
      "cohort": "Directed URL test",
      "prompt": "Visit https://rhythm90.io/ live and its linked pages if needed. Explain the quarter learning method, how many downloadable AI skills and chapter guides are offered, whether mini-app data is cloud synced, whether the worked quarter is a real customer case, and how Rhythm90 works alongside task tools. Cite retrieved pages and give short exact supporting quotes. Do not supply facts you cannot verify.",
      "capturedAt": "2026-10-23T02:17:17.125Z",
      "excerpts": [
        "Rhythm90 helps teams choose deliberate bets, notice useful signals, and use evidence to make the next quarter smarter.",
        "The living edition provides 14 updated chapter guides.",
        "They do not automatically sync to other browsers or teammates."
      ],
      "match": "Quoted graph wording; requested short supporting quotes.",
      "comparison": "These passages were present in the published graph and prepared Markdown, and absent from the captured original page. This comparison does not cover every other page or search cache.",
      "delivery": {
        "at": "2026-10-23 02:15:53 UTC",
        "representation": "html",
        "publication": "graph:25",
        "sha256": "0b7bf02db8f85ac61af5d18b90df3120596146fd825c3d0046d85baebff2b37d",
        "requester": "ChatGPT-User",
        "identity": "Provider IP check matched"
      },
      "artifacts": {
        "delivered": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/chatgpt-rhythm90-delivered.txt",
          "sha256": "0b7bf02db8f85ac61af5d18b90df3120596146fd825c3d0046d85baebff2b37d"
        },
        "original": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/chatgpt-rhythm90-original.txt",
          "sha256": "417b03fa09d2426463ca0176ef9dba8ccb917822a9bf183e6ea091149114a793"
        },
        "markdown": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/chatgpt-rhythm90-markdown.txt",
          "sha256": "af0b1e93de18988066131aeefdbcd8e672634126e0e7db01e0e1b8914c520860"
        }
      },
      "sourceUrl": "https://rhythm90.io/",
      "conversationAccess": "Account conversation retained privately; public excerpts are reproduced here. The private conversation URL is not a public share link."
    },
    {
      "id": "claude-rhythm90",
      "title": "A fictional example stays fictional",
      "site": "Rhythm90",
      "provider": "Claude",
      "cohort": "Directed URL test",
      "prompt": "Visit https://rhythm90.io/ live and its linked pages if needed. Explain the quarter learning method, how many downloadable AI skills and chapter guides are offered, whether mini-app data is cloud synced, whether the worked quarter is a real customer case, and how Rhythm90 works alongside task tools. Cite retrieved pages and give short exact supporting quotes. Do not supply facts you cannot verify.",
      "capturedAt": "2026-10-23T02:15:30.399Z",
      "excerpts": [
        "an illustrative teaching exercise, not a customer case study.",
        "They do not automatically sync to other browsers or teammates.",
        "one to three Plays, or one for a first pilot.",
        "The living edition provides 14 updated chapter guides.",
        "Rhythm90 does not replace Agile, Asana, or a campaign calendar."
      ],
      "match": "Quoted graph wording; requested short supporting quotes.",
      "comparison": "These passages were present in the published graph and prepared Markdown, and absent from the captured original page. This comparison does not cover every other page or search cache.",
      "delivery": {
        "at": "2026-10-23 02:15:09 UTC",
        "representation": "markdown",
        "publication": "graph:25",
        "sha256": "af0b1e93de18988066131aeefdbcd8e672634126e0e7db01e0e1b8914c520860",
        "requester": "Claude-User",
        "identity": "Declared User-Agent; no independent provider IP verification"
      },
      "artifacts": {
        "delivered": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/claude-rhythm90-delivered.txt",
          "sha256": "af0b1e93de18988066131aeefdbcd8e672634126e0e7db01e0e1b8914c520860"
        },
        "original": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/claude-rhythm90-original.txt",
          "sha256": "417b03fa09d2426463ca0176ef9dba8ccb917822a9bf183e6ea091149114a793"
        },
        "markdown": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/claude-rhythm90-markdown.txt",
          "sha256": "af0b1e93de18988066131aeefdbcd8e672634126e0e7db01e0e1b8914c520860"
        }
      },
      "sourceUrl": "https://rhythm90.io/",
      "conversationAccess": "Account conversation retained privately; public excerpts are reproduced here. The private conversation URL is not a public share link."
    },
    {
      "id": "claude-optiview",
      "title": "No promise of AI placement",
      "site": "Optiview",
      "provider": "Claude",
      "cohort": "Directed URL test",
      "prompt": "Visit https://optiview.ai/ live and linked product pages if needed. Explain how the published narrative combines with parsed website source, who controls approval and publication, how it differs from an AI visibility tracker, which connection methods it offers, and what it promises about retrieval and citations. Cite retrieved pages and include short exact supporting quotes. Do not infer guarantees.",
      "capturedAt": "2026-10-23T02:16:37.543Z",
      "excerpts": [
        "Optiview does not control an LLM’s answers or guarantee placement in them."
      ],
      "match": "Quoted graph wording; requested short supporting quotes.",
      "comparison": "These passages were present in the published graph and prepared Markdown, and absent from the captured original page. This comparison does not cover every other page or search cache.",
      "delivery": {
        "at": "2026-10-23 02:15:55 UTC",
        "representation": "markdown",
        "publication": "graph:19",
        "sha256": "3ef15226e62a1f889152a57a396d208f0d882851c6e12a9c341b0108e9db17b9",
        "requester": "Claude-User",
        "identity": "Declared User-Agent; no independent provider IP verification"
      },
      "artifacts": {
        "delivered": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/claude-optiview-delivered.txt",
          "sha256": "3ef15226e62a1f889152a57a396d208f0d882851c6e12a9c341b0108e9db17b9"
        },
        "original": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/claude-optiview-original.txt",
          "sha256": "66ec4d9ed0cb7202564a6ff6b86bd2cc50b0643ccfee6b4afc35d2741cf384ce"
        },
        "markdown": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/claude-optiview-markdown.txt",
          "sha256": "3ef15226e62a1f889152a57a396d208f0d882851c6e12a9c341b0108e9db17b9"
        }
      },
      "sourceUrl": "https://optiview.ai/",
      "conversationAccess": "Account conversation retained privately; public excerpts are reproduced here. The private conversation URL is not a public share link."
    },
    {
      "id": "chatgpt-optiview",
      "title": "Website source plus published brand context",
      "site": "Optiview",
      "provider": "ChatGPT",
      "cohort": "Directed URL test",
      "prompt": "Visit https://optiview.ai/ live and linked product pages if needed. Explain how the published narrative combines with parsed website source, who controls approval and publication, how it differs from an AI visibility tracker, which connection methods it offers, and what it promises about retrieval and citations. Cite retrieved pages and include short exact supporting quotes. Do not infer guarantees.",
      "capturedAt": "2026-10-23T02:18:47.712Z",
      "excerpts": [
        "Optiview turns complex website content into clean, structured Markdown and combines it with the brand narrative your team chooses to publish."
      ],
      "match": "Quoted graph wording; requested short supporting quotes.",
      "comparison": "These passages were present in the published graph and prepared Markdown, and absent from the captured original page. This comparison does not cover every other page or search cache.",
      "delivery": {
        "at": "2026-10-23 02:17:39 UTC",
        "representation": "html",
        "publication": "graph:19",
        "sha256": "1cf67782d4766c53c517408f491ee87e46af5241cd28362af7ac58470aa48666",
        "requester": "ChatGPT-User",
        "identity": "Provider IP check matched"
      },
      "artifacts": {
        "delivered": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/chatgpt-optiview-delivered.txt",
          "sha256": "1cf67782d4766c53c517408f491ee87e46af5241cd28362af7ac58470aa48666"
        },
        "original": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/chatgpt-optiview-original.txt",
          "sha256": "66ec4d9ed0cb7202564a6ff6b86bd2cc50b0643ccfee6b4afc35d2741cf384ce"
        },
        "markdown": {
          "url": "/proof/evidence-2026-10-22/chatgpt-optiview-markdown.txt",
          "sha256": "3ef15226e62a1f889152a57a396d208f0d882851c6e12a9c341b0108e9db17b9"
        }
      },
      "sourceUrl": "https://optiview.ai/",
      "conversationAccess": "Account conversation retained privately; public excerpts are reproduced here. The private conversation URL is not a public share link."
    }
  ],
  "methodology": {
    "selection": "Nine selected conversations, not nine independent replications of one benchmark. Seven directed URL tests plus two unbranded tests. No graph wording was pasted into these prompts. Directed tests requested exact supporting quotes.",
    "scope": "Four production sites with published Narrative Graphs: A5 Home Services, Learnings.org, Rhythm90 and Optiview. We operate these sites. Signed-in product accounts and temporary/incognito conversations are not a guarantee of an anonymous or unbiased ranking test.",
    "verification": "SHA-256 confirms retained response bytes match the production delivery record. Provider-IP status is separate from User-Agent. Timestamp and source/answer overlap support retrieval correlation, not per-conversation cryptographic attribution or proof of a model’s internal reasoning.",
    "wording": "Models summarize and paraphrase, and sometimes retain exact phrases. Quote matching normalizes case, whitespace and punctuation; it does not imply that the entire answer is copied.",
    "outcomes": "The broader unbranded study retained 64 prompt/product combinations (66 attempts after two error retries): 63 usable answers, 19 target-site mentions, 44 target omissions and one inconclusive timeout. Five conversations matched graph language; two also had fresh hash-matched delivery. Gemini supplied no qualifying example. These counts are descriptive, not an adoption or success rate.",
    "limits": "Selected positives are not typical-result, ranking, revenue, indexing or citation guarantees. HTML examples show prepared source plus graph delivered as HTML; they do not establish text/markdown on the wire. Public files omit account history, customer IDs, IP addresses and raw internal telemetry."
  }
}
