{
  "planned": 8,
  "completed": 8,
  "targetAppearances": 2,
  "targetOmissions": 6,
  "inconclusive": 0,
  "technicalRetries": 0,
  "method": "Two predeclared unbranded questions across all four providers. These are first-party selected, deliberately aligned specific-need questions, not broad category discovery or a controlled lift benchmark. No brand, URL, source wording or rescue hint is supplied. Preserve all omissions, refusals, failures and blocked attempts. No retry of a usable answer. One identical retry only for a technical failure after a five-minute allowance; never bypass a CAPTCHA.",
  "modes": [
    {
      "provider": "chatgpt",
      "mode": "Temporary chat, explicitly Unpersonalized; Medium effort; base model not independently confirmed"
    },
    {
      "provider": "claude",
      "mode": "Incognito; Sonnet 5.5 Medium"
    },
    {
      "provider": "perplexity",
      "mode": "Incognito; Search; free-plan interface with an advanced-search preview notice"
    },
    {
      "provider": "gemini",
      "mode": "Temporary chat; Pro"
    }
  ],
  "productionUnchanged": true,
  "limits": "Retain transcripts privately with hashes and publish sanitized answer excerpts/outcomes only. Existing proof and search caches may provide source wording; do not claim graph-exclusive causation. No claim of indexing, ingestion or citation improvement from traffic.",
  "records": [
    {
      "id": "chatgpt-reviewed-machine-source-delivery",
      "provider": "chatgpt",
      "prompt": "Please search current public web sources. Our agency wants to keep a client’s existing website while publishing an easier-to-read source for AI tools, including company facts that the client approves. Which products should we compare if we also need to inspect the content version and the responses actually served? Explain the review and publishing workflow, and distinguish delivery evidence from proof that an AI answer cited the company.",
      "kind": "unbranded specific-need question",
      "site": "optiview",
      "complete": true,
      "status": "target_omission",
      "targetMentioned": false,
      "targetLinks": [],
      "sourceLinks": [
        "https://siftserve.com/?utm_source=chatgpt.com",
        "https://aigentcandor.com/?utm_source=chatgpt.com",
        "https://www.tryreadable.ai/?utm_source=chatgpt.com",
        "https://developers.cloudflare.com/ai-crawl-control/?utm_source=chatgpt.com",
        "https://www.getnoan.com/?utm_source=chatgpt.com",
        "https://developers.cloudflare.com/fundamentals/reference/markdown-for-agents/?utm_source=chatgpt.com"
      ],
      "observed": "2026-10-28T22:30:49.638Z",
      "answerSha256": "28bcf72a11894c3b156e35496cdc4741ef0d1a0fbaf4995cb2ffe402af5633ad",
      "rawCaptureSha256": "d2933d3ed368a147c6f09a2c418c7a17100b4018a210472b9d80fdb07abc7bf8",
      "mode": "Temporary chat, explicitly Unpersonalized; Medium effort; base model not independently confirmed",
      "limitations": "First-party selected specific-need question. Brand and target URL were not supplied. An appearance or source link does not establish fresh graph retrieval or causation. Other sources, indexes, caches and public evidence archives may carry the same wording.",
      "answerFile": "/proof/refresh-20261028/chatgpt-reviewed-machine-source-delivery.json"
    },
    {
      "id": "chatgpt-workplace-language-reader-participation",
      "provider": "chatgpt",
      "prompt": "Please search current public web sources. I am making a lighthearted reading list for coworkers who are tired of business jargon. Which independent websites combine a funny dictionary of workplace language with things readers can try or contribute? Explain what is free, who the material is for, and whether the sites are entertainment or professional training.",
      "kind": "unbranded specific-need question",
      "site": "learnings",
      "complete": true,
      "status": "target_appearance",
      "targetMentioned": true,
      "targetLinks": [
        "https://learnings.org/?utm_source=chatgpt.com"
      ],
      "sourceLinks": [
        "https://learnings.org/?utm_source=chatgpt.com",
        "https://corpomode.com/?utm_source=chatgpt.com",
        "https://corporatewords.com/?utm_source=chatgpt.com",
        "https://jargonish.com/?utm_source=chatgpt.com",
        "https://www.defundhr.com/bingo?utm_source=chatgpt.com",
        "https://bizwordbingo.com/?utm_source=chatgpt.com"
      ],
      "observed": "2026-10-28T22:33:14.180Z",
      "answerSha256": "c2b65550722d13a0f6aedfe4391b034439297ed3f81f2de936c94854e6c9ba44",
      "rawCaptureSha256": "7cde19088ba128599c647f97163b15b881f43325de3d0bee348336203d5938e7",
      "mode": "Temporary chat, explicitly Unpersonalized; Medium effort; base model not independently confirmed",
      "limitations": "First-party selected specific-need question. Brand and target URL were not supplied. An appearance or source link does not establish fresh graph retrieval or causation. Other sources, indexes, caches and public evidence archives may carry the same wording.",
      "answerFile": "/proof/refresh-20261028/chatgpt-workplace-language-reader-participation.json"
    },
    {
      "id": "claude-reviewed-machine-source-delivery",
      "provider": "claude",
      "prompt": "Please search current public web sources. Our agency wants to keep a client’s existing website while publishing an easier-to-read source for AI tools, including company facts that the client approves. Which products should we compare if we also need to inspect the content version and the responses actually served? Explain the review and publishing workflow, and distinguish delivery evidence from proof that an AI answer cited the company.",
      "kind": "unbranded specific-need question",
      "site": "optiview",
      "complete": true,
      "status": "target_omission",
      "targetMentioned": false,
      "targetLinks": [],
      "sourceLinks": [
        "https://helpcenter.scrunchai.com/en/articles/13656392-agent-experience-platform-axp",
        "https://helpcenter.scrunchai.com/en/articles/12845899-how-axp-serves-content-to-ai-agents",
        "https://generatemore.ai/blog/my-scrunch-ai-visibility-review-saas-and-b2b-tech-focus",
        "https://developers.cloudflare.com/fundamentals/reference/markdown-for-agents",
        "https://66f4ea29.previews.developers.cloudflare.com/fundamentals/reference/markdown-for-agents/",
        "https://github.com/surendranb/agent-metrics/releases",
        "https://www.tryprofound.com/blog/introducing-agent-analytics",
        "https://www.xseek.io/blogs/articles/best-tools-to-track-ai-crawlers-on-your-website-2026",
        "https://www.tryprofound.com/features/agent-analytics",
        "https://nicklafferty.com/blog/what-is-agent-analytics/",
        "https://www.mcpbundles.com/skills/tryhikoo-mcp-481aaa3f46",
        "https://ppc.land/google-and-bing-say-no-separate-markdown-pages-for-ai-violate-search-policies/",
        "https://geosurge.ai/posts/cloaking-or-optimisation-rethinking-content-delivery-for-geo"
      ],
      "observed": "2026-10-28T22:30:49.868Z",
      "answerSha256": "6cfb8e6273cfef63ab7918dcf2b9a4675faa7d1035c163a2b855b3328ce35d7a",
      "rawCaptureSha256": "85748732f289c951d937c1d1a1f0aaee23f61ffc7f6540f9e2ca427fe3e356d7",
      "mode": "Incognito; Sonnet 5.5 Medium",
      "limitations": "First-party selected specific-need question. Brand and target URL were not supplied. An appearance or source link does not establish fresh graph retrieval or causation. Other sources, indexes, caches and public evidence archives may carry the same wording.",
      "answerFile": "/proof/refresh-20261028/claude-reviewed-machine-source-delivery.json"
    },
    {
      "id": "claude-workplace-language-reader-participation",
      "provider": "claude",
      "prompt": "Please search current public web sources. I am making a lighthearted reading list for coworkers who are tired of business jargon. Which independent websites combine a funny dictionary of workplace language with things readers can try or contribute? Explain what is free, who the material is for, and whether the sites are entertainment or professional training.",
      "kind": "unbranded specific-need question",
      "site": "learnings",
      "complete": true,
      "status": "target_omission",
      "targetMentioned": false,
      "targetLinks": [],
      "sourceLinks": [
        "https://laughingsquid.com/unsuck-it-helps-you-translate-terrible-business-jargon/",
        "https://plansponsor.com/?p=20634",
        "https://heytaco.com/tools/corporate-jargon-generator",
        "https://thestoryshack.com/tools/corporate-buzzword-generator/",
        "https://bingo.timvandevall.com/office-bingo",
        "https://jasperbernaers.com/bingo-card/",
        "https://amateurlexicography.substack.com/p/buzzword",
        "https://londonpublishingpartnership.co.uk/?p=4783",
        "https://www.publishersweekly.com/9781950496167"
      ],
      "observed": "2026-10-28T22:33:14.673Z",
      "answerSha256": "128463e40b85b37217aa77a28ef837a07f71d8e561002f815773037de604effa",
      "rawCaptureSha256": "eb1c9f01683e12c96af15f6d61679eb23bd31c29e9c4d95e15377539398bc1a0",
      "mode": "Incognito; Sonnet 5.5 Medium",
      "limitations": "First-party selected specific-need question. Brand and target URL were not supplied. An appearance or source link does not establish fresh graph retrieval or causation. Other sources, indexes, caches and public evidence archives may carry the same wording.",
      "answerFile": "/proof/refresh-20261028/claude-workplace-language-reader-participation.json"
    },
    {
      "id": "perplexity-reviewed-machine-source-delivery",
      "provider": "perplexity",
      "prompt": "Please search current public web sources. Our agency wants to keep a client’s existing website while publishing an easier-to-read source for AI tools, including company facts that the client approves. Which products should we compare if we also need to inspect the content version and the responses actually served? Explain the review and publishing workflow, and distinguish delivery evidence from proof that an AI answer cited the company.",
      "kind": "unbranded specific-need question",
      "site": "optiview",
      "complete": true,
      "status": "target_omission",
      "targetMentioned": false,
      "targetLinks": [],
      "sourceLinks": [
        "https://developers.cloudflare.com/fundamentals/reference/markdown-for-agents/",
        "https://wordpress.org/plugins/citelayer/",
        "https://knitknot.ai/",
        "https://ai.evm.io/help/how-evm-identifies-source-backed-facts",
        "https://digiday.com/media/perplexity-blocks-times-ads-served-to-ai-agents-calling-them-deceptive/",
        "https://ai.evm.io/help/glossary-knowledge",
        "https://ai.evm.io/help/verified-ai-crawlers",
        "https://ai.evm.io/help/missing-thin-or-stale-pages",
        "https://ai.evm.io/help/ai-assisted-knowledge-setup"
      ],
      "observed": "2026-10-28T22:30:50.051Z",
      "answerSha256": "6921c4e78fba6977b48a3da439ac97e5e3911de6a149269b0bb43e54957da7fa",
      "rawCaptureSha256": "12b6586fad066aa529e1c36e8ad4b7ab15cb23766cfebdbf9fdf855081bd9cf4",
      "mode": "Incognito; Search; free-plan interface with an advanced-search preview notice",
      "limitations": "First-party selected specific-need question. Brand and target URL were not supplied. An appearance or source link does not establish fresh graph retrieval or causation. Other sources, indexes, caches and public evidence archives may carry the same wording.",
      "answerFile": "/proof/refresh-20261028/perplexity-reviewed-machine-source-delivery.json"
    },
    {
      "id": "perplexity-workplace-language-reader-participation",
      "provider": "perplexity",
      "prompt": "Please search current public web sources. I am making a lighthearted reading list for coworkers who are tired of business jargon. Which independent websites combine a funny dictionary of workplace language with things readers can try or contribute? Explain what is free, who the material is for, and whether the sites are entertainment or professional training.",
      "kind": "unbranded specific-need question",
      "site": "learnings",
      "complete": true,
      "status": "target_appearance",
      "targetMentioned": true,
      "targetLinks": [
        "https://learnings.org/",
        "https://learnings.org/term/mission-critical",
        "https://learnings.org/term/bandwidth-v2"
      ],
      "sourceLinks": [
        "https://learnings.org/",
        "https://thecorporatedictionary.co.uk/",
        "https://thecorporatedictionary.co.uk/quiz",
        "https://bsdict.com/",
        "https://bsdict.com/about",
        "https://thecorporatedictionary.co.uk/term/quick-sync",
        "https://thecorporatedictionary.co.uk/term/deck",
        "https://bsdict.com/career-tools",
        "https://www.atlassian.com/blog/teamwork/6-examples-of-business-jargon-you-should-stop-using-now",
        "https://www.theforage.com/blog/basics/corporate-jargon",
        "https://uk.finance.yahoo.com/photos/26-funny-corporate-jargon-perplex-074114393/",
        "https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/buzz-word-bingo-just-stop-please-thgadvisors-bkutc",
        "https://www.sabrehq.com/post/buzzword-bingo-beware-of-corporate-hr-l-d-and-coach-jargon-dumbing-down-real-conversations-and-aut",
        "https://www.crossover.com/resources/64-corporate-jargon-examples-to-unfreeze-your-brain",
        "https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/test-yourself-corporate-jargon-quiz-laura-hale-brockway-els",
        "https://learnings.org/term/mission-critical",
        "https://learnings.org/term/bandwidth-v2",
        "https://news.workdaze.co/p/corporate-jargon-bingo",
        "https://corporatewords.com/",
        "https://corporatejargon.bingo/"
      ],
      "observed": "2026-10-28T22:33:14.821Z",
      "answerSha256": "69e401b26d3b2779190a63f2282c5bac47ba494a3ee580d34362776f9fda3d9a",
      "rawCaptureSha256": "b3d1519452266f24c015f908fdfa43999b17b6db9609cdda670ef4ceb4040f54",
      "mode": "Incognito; Search; free-plan interface with an advanced-search preview notice",
      "limitations": "First-party selected specific-need question. Brand and target URL were not supplied. An appearance or source link does not establish fresh graph retrieval or causation. Other sources, indexes, caches and public evidence archives may carry the same wording.",
      "answerFile": "/proof/refresh-20261028/perplexity-workplace-language-reader-participation.json"
    },
    {
      "id": "gemini-reviewed-machine-source-delivery",
      "provider": "gemini",
      "prompt": "Please search current public web sources. Our agency wants to keep a client’s existing website while publishing an easier-to-read source for AI tools, including company facts that the client approves. Which products should we compare if we also need to inspect the content version and the responses actually served? Explain the review and publishing workflow, and distinguish delivery evidence from proof that an AI answer cited the company.",
      "kind": "unbranded specific-need question",
      "site": "optiview",
      "complete": true,
      "status": "target_omission",
      "targetMentioned": false,
      "targetLinks": [],
      "sourceLinks": [],
      "observed": "2026-10-28T22:30:50.232Z",
      "answerSha256": "860f6f3d69b022b4641d9f917e50e8aa36a95b563effa3306c77e89ee0c2a5d4",
      "rawCaptureSha256": "88337da7b2e96c8050a5716c4d4048d3c634d9baa5e0d532ddcf58acf3308c67",
      "mode": "Temporary chat; Pro",
      "limitations": "First-party selected specific-need question. Brand and target URL were not supplied. An appearance or source link does not establish fresh graph retrieval or causation. Other sources, indexes, caches and public evidence archives may carry the same wording.",
      "answerFile": "/proof/refresh-20261028/gemini-reviewed-machine-source-delivery.json"
    },
    {
      "id": "gemini-workplace-language-reader-participation",
      "provider": "gemini",
      "prompt": "Please search current public web sources. I am making a lighthearted reading list for coworkers who are tired of business jargon. Which independent websites combine a funny dictionary of workplace language with things readers can try or contribute? Explain what is free, who the material is for, and whether the sites are entertainment or professional training.",
      "kind": "unbranded specific-need question",
      "site": "learnings",
      "complete": true,
      "status": "target_omission",
      "targetMentioned": false,
      "targetLinks": [],
      "sourceLinks": [],
      "observed": "2026-10-28T22:33:15.058Z",
      "answerSha256": "997e2c81411ffe78ab6c789d7e62babd8c850b39d1785f101b9e5318e73909b3",
      "rawCaptureSha256": "3b8911ab6331ef07c2f71aa68311a7297f388ebf277ab4ca2b22a3d8b6e57c47",
      "mode": "Temporary chat; Pro",
      "limitations": "First-party selected specific-need question. Brand and target URL were not supplied. An appearance or source link does not establish fresh graph retrieval or causation. Other sources, indexes, caches and public evidence archives may carry the same wording.",
      "answerFile": "/proof/refresh-20261028/gemini-workplace-language-reader-participation.json"
    }
  ]
}
